Hawkes Bay families struggle moving on from transitional housing

Nov 8, 2017 | News

In the Herald today they reported that the Ministry of Social Development, which bought the motel to provide “transitional housing” amid a widespread homeless problem throughout the country, says there are 97 transitional housing places in Napier, and it’s trying to “secure” another 125.

Read more: Affording a home in Hawke’s Bay gets tougher
Government spending millions on Hawke’s Bay emergency housing

While ministry deputy chief executive housing Scott Gallacher said the MSD is aware that the National Collective of Independent Women’s Refuges, running the accommodation and “operating as Triple S”, has asked a small number of families to leave the facilities “as their behaviour has put other families at risk,” the women say conditions of the tenancy treat them “like criminals” and make the facilities “like Colditz”.

The women are not Women’s Refuge referrals, but say that because of a shortage of housing in Hawke’s Bay they had no option to accept restrictive conditions so they had somewhere to live.

Conditions include being allowed visitors only between 9am and 3pm, but Tania Powell has also been told she is out for a strongly-denied breach of conditions prohibiting use of illicit drugs or alcohol on site or being on-site intoxicated.

“I hate alcohol,” she said as she decided to speak publicly on the issue, saying she believed claims of intoxication were based on CCTV images – “the cameras are everywhere” – of her returning at night.

“I walk with a limp,” she says.

The women have also been told they’ve breached conditions by not showing “weekly evidence of house applications”, but Nina Rewi says the women don’t choose to live where they have been living and are constantly looking for homes – all in the same small pool of housing.

“These are our homes, we have nothing else,” said Ms Rewi.

Mr Gallacher said the ministry’s “purchasing strategy” sets out how and where it will deliver social housing places over the next four years.

“It shows that we are looking to secure an additional 125 income-related rent-subsidised places in Napier,” he said.

“We are working with a range of other agencies, including Housing New Zealand, to increase housing supply within Hawke’s Bay.”

Triple S began accepting referrals in late July, with tenants receiving wraparound services to address issues related to their homelessness, Mr Gallacher said.

Occupancy agreements set out what was expected from tenants and the provider, to ensure the safety of all families in the facility, he said.

Collective of Independent Women’s Refuges manager Julie Hart said Triple S hosts up to 12 families.

“When we were designing our service we looked at what our objectives were, hence the name Triple S; Safe, Secure, Short-term accommodation for women and children affected by homelessness,” she said.

“We looked at the vulnerability of children so the rules are around restricted visitor hours; that we are a drug and alcohol free site; no criminal activities and other common courtesies.

“A family is only ever moved on if we have, after repeated efforts, no success in getting them to adhere to the rules and that the ones that are being breeched are impacting on other families or whanau.”

Patoka man Cliff Rogers became aware of the women’s plight and says that as a human right everyone has a right to a roof over their head and a warm, liveable home.

None of the women has drugs or violence convictions, and in some cases conditions have interfered with fathers legitimate rights to visit their children, because they can’t visit them outside of school hours, they say.

“These people have done nothing wrong,” Mr Rogers said.

“They are simply people who are struggling to get along, and there is a shortage of housing in Napier, but they are being treated like criminals. You can’t just lock them up in a cage.”

He said there’d been no movement in attempts to get some leeway, despite it appearing there are several units in the complex.

The women have meetings with the Salvation Army in the hope some accommodation may become available.

Recent articles

Annual Report

2021/22 CHA Annual Report

2021/22 CHA Annual Report

Strategic Plan

CHA’s 2022-2023 Strategic Workplan

CHA’s 2022-2023 Strategic Workplan

Featured Network

Residential Tenancies Act Community of Practice

Residential Tenancies Act Community of Practice

Our Place

Our Place Report 2017

Our Place Report 2017

Case Studies

Media Releases



Community Housing Aotearoa newsletter – November 28, 2022

Welcome to our latest newsletter. We cover the latest staff news, we seek feedback on our Conference topics, outline what submissions are currently being prepared, plus highlight a number of community and partner events. Community Housing Aotearoa newsletter November...

Community Housing Aotearoa newsletter – November 14, 2022

Welcome to our latest newsletter. We cover the latest staff news, Auckland's CHP network latest event, we seek feedback on our Conference topics, outline what submissions are currently being prepared, plus highlight a number of community and partner events. Community...

Community Housing Aotearoa Newsletter – October 31, 2022

Welcome to our latest newsletter. We cover the release of our Annual Report and our AGM, we seek feedback on our Conference topics, outline what submissions are currently being prepared, summarise the VUW Interns' work to produce CHRA Registration and Methamphetamine...


CHA’s Submission on the Charities Amendment Bill

CHA submitted to the Social Services and Community Committee on the Charities Amendment Bill. We supported a robust and fully inclusive review be done through an independent body to address underlying issues that our sector faces and ensure lasting charities. The...



CHA 2022 Annual Report and Audited Accounts

What a year for our Community Housing Aotearoa Ngā Wharerau o Aotearoa team. Our Annual Report highlights our service delivery, including: - 16 submissions to central and local government. - 30 trainings and events delivered on topics ranging from public health...

CHA’s Methamphetamine Harm-Reduction Handbook

CHA has developed a Methamphetamine Harm-Reduction Handbook - with consultation from the NZ Drug Foundation - with advice for providers, tenants, and policy-makers. This resource can be read below: Methamphetamine Harm-Reduction Handbook


Community Housing Aotearoa

Contact Us

Contact Info

Level 11, Ranchhod Tower,
39 The Terrace /
102-112 Lambton Quay
PO Box 11543
Wellington 6142

+04 385 8722


Follow On