KiwiBuild a ‘massive political distraction’

Jan 24, 2019 | News

“The government could lower unit construction costs in many ways, as it is well aware,” former Business Roundtable economist Bryce Wilkinson says in a new research note today. It could ease up on red tape, improve the supply of urban land by removing regulatory restrictions, and encourage high-rise construction to improve economies of scale.

Indeed, all of these were the focus of other government policies, such as creating an Urban Development Authority this year to bypass normal Resource Management Act processes to fast-track housing developments in high-cost areas like Auckland.

“None of these initiatives would require the government to be a house builder,” says Wilkinson. He argues that, “if KiwiBuild makes no difference to the future land-inclusive cost of building a new home beyond year 10, it makes no difference to house prices in the long run.”

Housing and Urban Development Minister Phil Twyford took advice from the NZ Initiative when in Opposition and was persuaded by its argument that artificially creating urban boundaries was pushing up the cost of land for housing within those boundaries. He convinced the Labour Party to adopt policy abolishing urban-rural boundaries.

He is also pursuing long-term bond financing for essential infrastructure, the up-front cost of which is often blamed for making new houses unaffordable.

However, KiwiBuild was failing on the objectives it was established for, while being the flagship initiative for housing affordability solutions.

“KiwiBuild cannot hope to materially increase home ownership proportions – the original 2012 objective,” the NZ Initiative report says. “Additional housing, if achieved, will likely lift renting and ownership more or less in tandem.”

In other words, focusing on rates of home ownership as a measure the policy’s success was setting it up for political failure.

KiwiBuild was also now “for the relatively well-off”, now that the price of a KiwiBuild home was around twice the $300,000 target set in the original policy.

It was “not about social housing to help those at the bottom” or “about helping struggling first-home buyers”.

As the policy has morphed from actively building new homes to underwriting the construction of homes by private developers at a certain price, KiwiBuild had also effectively become a subsidy scheme, the report says.

“It cannot hope to increase housing stock sustainably. Only enduring lower property prices can induce people to own more dwellings than otherwise. KiwiBuild reduces neither land values nor constructions at the margin.” As a result, its main effect is to change “the composition of the housing stock by decree rather than by public demand”.

KiwiBuild constituted “a massive political and bureaucratic distraction from what is really needed – direct action to reduce land values and construction costs”.

“The government is ensnared by incompatible commitments to help relatively well-off first home buyers without subsidising them and to deliver homes that people would not want to buy if unsubsidised. Either outcome is politically embarrassing.

“KiwiBuild has become Housing Minister Phil Twyford’s tar baby,” the report says.

Recent articles

Annual Report

CHA’s Annual Report for 1st July 2019 to 30th June 2020

CHA’s Annual Report for 1st July 2019 to 30th June 2020

Strategic Plan

CHA’s Strategic Plan 2018

CHA’s Strategic Plan 2018

Featured Network

Residential Tenancies Act Community of Practice

Residential Tenancies Act Community of Practice

Our Place

Our Place 2017

Our Place 2017

Case Studies

Media Releases

The Shift Aotearoa conference 2021 issues papers released

Community Housing Aotearoa’s three pre-conference work programmes are kicking off next week with initial zoom meetings in the Narrative Transformation and Housing System Settings streams scheduled for Tuesday 26 January at 10AM and 1PM respectively. Issues papers to...

News

CHA Level 4 Guidance Document 8 September

CHA Level 4 Guidance Document 8 September Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) has put together this document to consolidate information, contacts, resources and advice to help you in your day to day service delivery and decision making. It will be updated as new...

Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) COVID-19 Update 26 August 2021

Message from CHA's Chief Executive, Productivity Commission Submission - Include Housing in the Terms of Reference, CHA's support for members, sharing ideas and issues, Ministry of Health information and advice, Government support for your organisation, important...

Newsletters

Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) Newsletter 30 August 2021

Message from Chief Executive, Support for Members, CHA Regional Event Series, #right2housing - Episode 2, Community Finance named as finalists at Sustainable Business Awards, Feedback sought on draft strategy and planning policy for housing measures, An update on the...

Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) Newsletter 18 August 2021

Community Housing Aotearoa COVID-19 Update, Message from CHA's Chief Executive, CHA's support for members, Sharing ideas and issues, Ministry of Health information and advice, Government support for your organisation. Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) Newsletter 18...

Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) Newsletter 16 August 2021

Warm Welcome for CHA's new Chief Executive, CHA Regional Event Series, Masterclass Webinar on Place-based initiatives: Save the Date! Government Reinstates Operating Supplement. On-going Engagement Underway - HRC Framework Guidelines on the #right2housing in Action....

Community Housing Aotearoa (CHA) Newsletter 3 August 2021

CHA Regional Event Series, Human Rights Commission Framework Guidelines on the Right to a Decent Home, Stories of Homelessness: When the Dominoes Start to Fall, Tenancy Management - Code of Practice, In the News, EVENTS, Upcoming Homestar v5 Events. Community Housing...

Submissions

Legislation

Reports

Te Whakaruruhau Report

The Te Whakaruruhau Report establishes the peak body services to the Homelessness Sector by Te Matapihi he Tirohanga mō te IwiTrust and Community Housing Aotearoa. The report can be found here: Te Whakaruruhau September 2020

Research

Following the money

http://www.buildingbetter.nz/publications/contestable_research_projects/Saville-Smith_2018_following_the_money.pdf

BRANZ research report on ‘exceeding the minimum’ released

This report looks at the question: why don’t landlords choose features that exceed the minimum building standards and what are the enablers to changing this? The aim is to identify the barriers to an improved rental stock and potential solutions to overcome the...

Community Housing Aotearoa

Contact Us

Contact Info

Level 11, Ranchhod Tower,
39 The Terrace /
102-112 Lambton Quay
PO Box 11543
Wellington 6142

+04 385 8722

support@communityhousing.org.nz

Follow On